Routes to Grassroots
Routes to Grassroutes where we trace Personal Journeys into Collective Action
For some, this journey begins with a memory. For others, with a moment of injustice they could not ignore. Sometimes it begins in their own neighborhood, and sometimes in a community far from the life they once imagined for themselves.
Routes to GrassRoots is a podcast featuring conversations with people whose personal journeys led them to grassroots action and community-driven change. We’ll speak with organizers, activists, volunteers, social entrepreneurs, and changemakers about the experiences that shaped them, the communities that changed them, and the choices that turned concern into commitment.
In a planet upended by war, strife, injustice and darkness; one where we often find ourselves in dispair complaining, much like Frodo from Tolkein’s world "I wish it need not have happened in my time," to which the wise Galdalf replies "So do I, and so do all who live to see such times. But that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us."
We hope you join us in this quest, and give a little bit of your time to discover pathways to building a different, brighter, world.
Routes to Grassroots
Episode 1. Kalpana on "A Woman of No Consequence"
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Kalpana Karunakaran is an academic, a writer, an activist, and a teacher at IIT Madras, where she researches gender, poverty, and labor movements. She has written a stunning book, ironically titled A Woman of No Consequence, which is the subject of our conversation, where she turns her anthropologist’s lens on her family’s written treasures, specifcally those of her grandmother, Pankajam.
Through this conversation we dive deep into the topic of moving in the world as a woman. We look at how the questions of a woman's work, her worth and consequence have changed - or more importantly have remained the same - over the past 100 years or so. The scope may sound vast and technical but the conversation unfolds like a fireside chat between friends sharing a warm cuppa.
You can order a copy a book at Thriftbooks here.
For more check out some reviews of Kalpana's book:
If the conversation moves you enough to write a comment - note that we have a giveaway for the first 5 commenters on this episode.
This podcast is made possible by Association for India’s Development or AID, a 501(c)3 charitable organization advancing sustainable development, social justice and disaster relief in India. You can find more about AID's work at www.aidindia.org
Speaker 2: 00:00
And who is it but the people I love who turn out to then ask me to not resist, to conform? Her grandmother, her mother's uh sister, younger sister, her father, all of them really, and that whole extended network of kit and kin and cousins and clan, right? All of them play a very active part in telling a young girl to stay put in to know her place in society. And Pankajam is pointing her fingers exactly there.
Speaker 1: 00:34
Welcome
Speaker 1: 00:34
to episode one of Roots to Grassroots, where we trace personal journeys into collective action. I'm your host, Sonica.
Speaker: 00:42
And I'm your co-host, Aravinda.
Speaker 1: 00:45
Our guest today is a woman who completely refuses to be boxed in. Kalpana Karunakaran is an academic, a writer, an activist, and a teacher at IIT Madras, where she researches gender, poverty, and labor movements. Another remarkable aspect of our guest is the legacy of pathbreaking women in her family and their shared tradition of biographical and autobiographical writing, which is the reason we are talking to her today. Kalpana has written this stunning book, which is ironically titled A Woman of No Consequence, where she turns her anthropologist's lens on her family's written treasures. With the attention to detail of a Raja Rabi Varma painting and the immersive world-making of Anne Pachette, Kalpana presents us a story that compels one to think critically about questions of worth and consequence in the context of the invisible web of shelbies that constrains women's lives across eras. I am absolutely thrilled to dive into this book today, alongside my co-host, Arvinda Pilalamari. Kalpana, welcome to the show.
Speaker 2: 01:48
Thank you so much, Sonica. Thank you, Arvinda. I'm so excited to be on this podcast.
Speaker 1: 01:54
Great. Alright, so before we dive in, just a quick note for our listeners. We will be discussing key themes of the book that I mentioned, but we promise to keep the conversation completely spoiler-free. You don't need to have read this book to enjoy this chat, although we highly recommend grabbing a copy. Plus, if you stick around until the end, we'll tell you how to enter a giveaway for a copy of your own. So with that, let's jump right into
Speaker 1: 02:20
it. Kalfana. My first question, I wanted to start with talking about your personal journey to this project. What drew you or compelled you to sit down and write your grandmother's story? And while you're at it, tell us a little about this mysterious wooden box.
Speaker 2: 02:37
So, Sonica, I must begin with a confession. And the confession is that this book was entirely unintentional. I did not set out to write a book on the life of my maternal grandmother. I set out to write a book on the life and times and the political activism of my mother, Maitili. Maitili Sivaraman was a fairly well-known, very well-loved and well-respected political organizer and public figure in Tamunada and elsewhere in India, nationally as well. She was a woman of consequence in a very visible manner. I had written essays about Maitili in Tamari and English, and I wanted to turn my attention to finally attempting a full book on her. A political biography, come personal memoir of sorts. And I think this was in the summer of 2017, if I'm not mistaken. I was looking for material in my house. My mother was a great one for keeping in place all her papers, her files, her diaries, etc. And therefore, this book project meant that I would have to first and foremost look for material in my own house. And in the process of doing that, I found this little wooden box. So I knew it belonged to my grandmother, and I knew it contained her papers and her writings. So there was no surprise here, really. So I opened the box, therefore, hoping to find some material that would also be relevant to Michael's life, my mother's life. And it was in the process of doing that that I began this journey of writing about Panka Jam, my grandmother. Because I found that she had been writing about her life. I found that she had been writing an autobiography for close to five decades, uh, starting from 1949 right up to the mid-1990s. I found that she had been writing her autobiography was written in English, but she had also been writing stories, short stories in Tamil as well as in English, and these stories were actually the story of her own life. So this rich material then gave me this fascinating insight into what it meant to be a young child, and then a teenager, an adolescent, and then a young wife, a young bride, and then a a mother, a mother of five children in the 1910s, the 1920s, the 1930s, the 1940s, right? And then I also found that she had been a fantastic writer. Her writing was so evocative. It brought to life an era. It was, in fact, rich material to reconstruct her life in the context of her times. And therefore, this book became a book about Pankajam, about my grandmother, and not about
Speaker 2: 05:30
Maitli, my mother.
Speaker 1: 05:32
Your dedication says for Pankajam, my beloved gran. And you know, that's sort of one of the first things one notices as you get into your book that you're very consistent with referring to her with her first name. I want you to talk a little bit about that choice and sort of a related question is how do you characterize this book? Is it a memoir? Is it a biography? It's a family history. What is it?
Speaker 2: 05:59
So let me address the first question that you asked, Sonica, which is that why is it that I refer to her always by her name and not just to her, but to all the characters in the book? That's a question I find that uh I'm repeatedly asked whenever I talk about the book with readers, all of whom are struck by the fact that everybody, including my mother, my father, my maternal uncles and aunts, their wives, etc., all of them appear as characters who are always referred to by their first names. And I think part of, well, one of it, the obvious reason was so that the story flows easily. But it also helped me in other ways, which were important in my writing of this book, which is that it provided me the distance emotionally and personally the distance that I needed to be able to write about people I had grown up amongst, right? Authority figures in my life. As a child, these were the adults in my life world. People I also happen to love quite a bit. And therefore, to be able to write about their lives, including their personal lives, their married lives, etc., I needed to find this distance. And I must say that it helped that I began to, in using their first names, I began to think of them as historical characters. And therefore, it became my job to reconstruct their lives and actions and decisions and to place it against the setting, social setting, and the context of their time, which also helps me address your second question, which is how do I see this book? How would I define it? And I think it would be, I mean, when I talk about it, I would say it's the reconstruction of the life of my maternal grandmother. And then I would add by saying it's as much a social history as it is, in a sense, a personal history or a biography. Because that I think is how I always thought about this book, which is that the personal and the biographical and the social and the historical would flow together and would become the tapestry that is the book.
Speaker 1: 08:05
Yeah, that's very beautifully encapsulated. So I want to dive right into
Speaker 1: 08:10
the book. Let's set the historical stage for this. Panku Jam was born in 1911, I believe. Is that correct? Absolutely right. Yeah. So this was a time which was governed by this, you know, invisible framework of deep constraints for women, right? Rules justified by custom or religion or caste status that women often internalize just to survive. So very early in this book, since we start with, you know, since Panka Jam starts writing about her early years, she talks about her mother, Suba Lakshmi. So Supa Lakshmi, who was married at the age of 11 and became mother at the age of 14, made a radical choice. Supa Lakshmi ran away from her husband just to ensure that her daughter could get a school education. That choice was so scandalous for the time that decades later, when Panka Jam was writing about it, she felt the need to distort the facts a little bit so as not to sort of cast a shadow on her own mother. What was it that drove Subhalakshmi to push past the limits of her era like that?
Speaker 2: 09:17
Two things, Sonica, I think, are important. One is, of course, Subhalakshmi herself is a person. She was a remarkable woman for any time, not just for her times, I think. A woman who devoured books, a woman who had a very much a mind of her own, and that was simply a part of who she was, and that enabled her her own wide reading. And of course, the sense that I'm sure she felt very, very keenly, very acutely that the lack of options in her own life, her own unhappy marriage, made her stay in that, stay trapped in that unhappy marriage. And she wanted her daughter to have the sort of opportunities that she could not have. And girls' education was just beginning to expand then. And therefore, she felt that she had to take this decision, run away from her husband, take her daughter to Madras to be able to put her in a school. But the other point here, which is equally important, is that she had a natal family. Her mother and her brother, so Subhalakshmi's brother and Suvalakshmi's mother, who had a household in Madras and who were willing to and ready to receive Suvalakshmi and her daughter Pankajam to provide that infrastructure, to be welcoming, and to help her admit Pankajam in school. Who's ever heard of doing this, of committing such an act? Then what could Subalakshmi have done? She would have had to go back to that seaside village where there was no school at all in the vicinity and go back to her husband. So also the fact that the native family was willing to back her, I think enabled her to take this. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 1: 11:03
That is actually such an important point. And it's also the subject of my next question. Most often, society offers this sort of an all-or-nothing bargain that you talked about. Like, you know, what if the family had said, go back, nobody has ever heard of a woman running away from your husband. But that is not the norm. That was not the norm then. I would even argue that's probably not the norm even to our day, you know, probably more than a century after that incident. Typically, a society generally offers either you conform to the rules of the society or you lose your financial and emotional safety net. In fact, Punkajim herself, writing in the 1930s, I believe she was writing a fictional story, which she often used to not only let out her own emotions, but also tell her own personal story in a sort of veiled manner. She writes this line that a male character says to a woman or a girl character that women should put up with hardship and neglect in life patiently and never complain. It might sound shocking, but I've in fact heard a version of that exact phrase firsthand in my own circles in recent times. So as I was reading about it, I was wondered how interesting it is that Panka Jam's life represents a rebellion against this kind of thinking without, in fact,
Speaker 1: 12:20
her coming across as a rebel. She is, in a way, a rebel in conformers' clothing. What do you say to that?
Speaker 2: 12:26
No, I completely agree with you. And I think it's easy to overlook that. It's easy to overlook that because on the face of it, from the outside, she led this very, very middle class, very normative life, housewife, respectable mother of five children, a devoted wife, and so on. And that seems to have been the story of her life, like any other woman's. But at the same time, here was this woman who had been enabled by the fact that she could read and write, and who had, like her own mother, this enormous appetite, this hunger for books, and that this reading, reading the world classics, the English classics, all of it meant that it gave her a window into other worlds, other ways of living, other choices that women were could make for themselves, such as the character Joe, Josephine March in The Little Women by L. M. Alcott. So I think what this reading then did was that it allowed Pankajam, who was growing up, who was a little child of eight, nine years old, in a tiny village, seaside village on the Coromandel coast in the Madras presidency in the 1910s, to hear about somebody called Josephine March, a girl who refused to conform because she was of the four March sisters in the Little Women, she was the one who was the most independent. She was the most fiery in her spirit. Right? She would run away and climb trees and write plays and stage plays. And all of this meant that Pankajam knew that there were many different ways of being a young woman or of being a young girl. And I think, therefore, through her life, then, through the act of continuously reading and through the act of writing, writing about her life, writing these stories, writing essays, writing poetry. And then later, as you'll see in the book, as you have already seen, forming friendships across all kinds of social barriers. All of this meant that she managed to live out an extraordinary life, even while she seemed to be just a housewife, a mother of five children, and a wife. She was a radical, but then she didn't appear to be one. Right, right.
Speaker 1: 14:36
Rebel in conformance clothing. Okay, so my next question is it's
Speaker 1: 14:40
sort of a two-parter. Like there's a concept in philosophy called intrahistoria, which is this idea that while traditional history focuses on big events, you know, like big waves, like wars and political movements and key, typically male political figures, there's an entire ocean of unrecorded, everyday lived reality beneath it. And I want to acknowledge that you have used this concept in your narrative. You weave these two beautifully, where you stop the narrative sometimes of Pankajam's life story just to give us a sense of what is happening in the environment and the zeitgeist around her, to situate us from a historical societal perspective of what's happening. And so there's this particular period, right? We talked about Suba Lakshmi moving to Madras to be able to start a formal education. But here, I think in the 1920s, you pause the story a little bit and you talk a little bit about the freedom movement and what's happening around in that time period. This is also a very pivotal moment in Bankajam's life because it marks the end of her formal education. Finally, she gets this lease of six years to go through this formal education, but then the web kind of constricts around her and she has to leave and go back to live with her father. But interestingly, in her life narrative, her education actually doesn't end at that time, right? She continues to read, to write, as you said, form friendships, travel across cultures and across countries. And I know that you also have a background in education. So I wondered your thoughts on what does this chapter in Panku Jim's life, what does it tell us about the role of structured learning in our times?
Speaker 2: 16:30
I love the fact that you refer to that period, those six years. She calls it the six happiest years of my life, when she had an opportunity to receive formal school education for the first time. The first time she steps into a school, she's about 10 years old, and then she's pulled out of school against her wishes. She's actually, she goes out of school kicking and screaming and weeping. So this is she's about 16 and she's in the middle of class 9. She hasn't even been allowed to take her half-yearly exams, right? Because she has to be married off the next year. So this is that period when Pankajam's story, and therefore my book, also gives us a sense of what it was like to be living in Madras in the 1920s, to be part of to witness really, to witness the non-cooperation movement, to witness the black flag protesters, to witness also to be in the beach, to be the sands of the marina and hear Congress leaders speaking, Subramanya Bharati, the Tamil nationalist poet, to hear, to see Gandhi at uh very, very close quarters. So one gets a sense also then really of the social churning of the time. I found that in Pankfajam's writing of her. Because and Pankajam is also passing her life story. And in fact, I found that she had written this extensive essay on what it meant to be a citizen of Madras in the 1920s and the 1930s, or a resident really. Nobody was a citizen back then. We hadn't, we were not independent as a nation, but to be really a resident of Madras, of the city of the great city of Madras, as she calls it. So all of this then allowed me to write the story, which is also really about Madras, the city, about the independence movement as well, to bring that into the book, to bring that into Pankacham's life and to place her life against that larger story. At the same time, and you make this right point, that while she is pulled out of school, she does not, her education does not really end there because she goes on then to acquire education by constant reading. So, what is formal education then? What is structured education then? If you can continue to learn, to be curious, to stay, to have a life of the mind, to keep your mind alive, to remain intellectually curious and deeply interested in everything in the universe around you, in science, in history, in geology, in geography, in all life forms, right? In plants, in insects, in birds. Because there was everything that she was interested in, the origin of the Himalayas, the origin of the human species, how did Homo sapiens evolve? Where did they come from? Who were the ancestors of humans? So all of this was part of the knowledge that she acquired through her extensive reading and conversations and letters with friends through the course of her life. So then what did the school life mean? I think what she makes us see is school life is really the time in your life that you are with peer your age, right? When you can be silly, you can be boisterous, it's a classroom full of schoolgirls who are making fun of their teachers in the mid-1920s, right? It's school sports, it's school tournaments, it's about a child who feels that she's unjustly got a black mug, and therefore she reports a teacher to a headmistress, and in the process acquires the confidence to talk back to authority figures. So all of this then gives us really the sense that school life is really about the camaraderie. It's really about the friendship. It's about seeing your dreams, right? Your anxieties, maybe your ambitions, your desires, your ideals reflected back in the lives of your peer, your schoolmates, your classmates, right? And that is what she lost when she was pulled out of school, even as the education continues beyond and well outside the parameters of formal learning or a structured learning environment.
Speaker 1: 20:34
Well, you described school life so beautifully, it almost makes me want to go back to school. All right, Arvinda.
Speaker: 20:43
Thank you, Sonica. It has been such a fascinating discussion. And I can't help jumping off of one of the points that Sonica has already alluded to. Some of the questions Punkajam faced about her placing her family and household duties before herself and to conform to social expectations even at the cost of her own freedom and happiness, and how these questions remain relevant even today. I'll just quote something that I read on page 150. Understanding of consent had little to do with the more radical question of women's willingness to marry or their agency in the conjugal relationship. And these are questions that Punkajim faced head-on, or wrote about at least. So it's easy to imagine that these have to do with rural India or previous generations, but actually these ideas have not really faded away and may even be experiencing a resurgence, even though women have the opportunity to read freely. So if Punkajem credits reading with her awakening, it wasn't just the access to books and reading. So what is so extraordinary about Pankajam in her ability to raise these questions in her time?
Speaker 2: 21:57
What is extraordinary about Pankajam was Sense that she always had a sense that the labor that she performed on an everyday basis, the labor of raising children, of keeping a home together, of ensuring that all her five children shared, imbibed, in a sense, inherited her love of people, her love of the universe, her freedom from prejudice, her ability to see the social universe as something that must be experienced and explored to the fullest. All that labor, she always felt, and that comes through quite clearly in her writing, that must count for something. And that must be recorded, that must be chronicled, that must belong in the annals of somebody's history somewhere, right? Right, right. I think she was conscious, and this is the remarkable thing about her, that while this new nation is being formed post-1947, there's a all this energy, enthusiasm, and optimism, and idealism, of course, that goes into building a new nation, the promise of a new nation, or the idealism of the early years of the Nairobian era. Pankajam was very, very conscious that she was bringing that same energy, enthusiasm, and optimism into racing her family. I think she was aware in some ways that, and she was because she was seems to be asking herself this question periodically through these notes, these introspective notes that she writes on her 60th birthday, then her 70th and then her 80th, and so on, right? Those milestone birthdays. She's asking, what is the meaning of my life? And the fact that I have poured so much of myself into being part of this nation-building exercise. And she doesn't use those, that's my language. That's not her language, right? But I can see that that is what she's hinting at. That's why is she not contributing to nation building? Why is she not an actor, an agent, an enthusiastic participant in building citizens of a new India? And that is the question that she seems to be asking us. And she's saying that my life must matter too, even if I am this mere, ordinary, uneventful housewife. And if if this is the life that I've led, and yet it must matter, and yet it must count. Because I have been part of this exercise of building a new nation. And I think that's the tone also and the spirit that also helped me make the links between the nation-building chapters in the book, what comes after independence, and the way in which Punkajam is building a home and a family.
Speaker: 24:30
That is so amazing. And I have to say, you weave those together so beautifully. I think that you, in that way, have really done justice to the feelings that she has poured in to writing about her life and recognizing its importance. And
Speaker: 24:47
that actually brings me to my question about the title. So on page 94, the fictional Mina argues with her grandfather, who tells her, quote, It is most becoming of a woman to be self-effacing and gentle, child. Remember how Savitri and Sita were. So Pankajam in describing her writing and herself alternates between a self-effacing description like unremarkable, ordinary, no consequence, and full melodrama calling her writing an insight into the vortex of a soul thrown entirely on itself. So could the book have been titled An Insight into the Vortex or A Soul Thrown Entirely on Itself, or even an insight into the vortex of a soul thrown entirely on itself, in opting for the self-effacing title, which the reader is expected not to take at face value? What were you considering about the presentation of Punkajam?
Speaker 2: 25:50
So I think I was hoping that the title would be an in something that would intrigue a reader, you know, pick somebody's curiosity, a potential reader's curiosity. I mean, if it's a woman of no consequence after all, why does this woman merit a book? Why is her photograph share staring at me from this book cover? And I think it's always with this irony that I'm I'm sort of also, and I think what your question also raises is why did Pankajam feel the need to be so self-effacing, right? Right. In many ways, her tone is very self-assured. When she writes about her life, she's talking directly to the reader. She's constantly invoking a reader, right? And she speaks to that reader, her tone is warm and inviting, but she speaks to that reader with confidence. She knows that she's a storyteller. So then why this self-effect effacing tone? Why this modesty? Excessively, it might seem, she was, I mean, doing two things. So one thing is that she tells you at the outset that I'm not a woman of our times, by which she means, you know, one of the Sarojari Naidu's or one of the nationalist heroes, right? Because those were, and she begins to write the story of her life, it's 1949. So clearly, then there were already women who were in the forefront of the anti-colonial movement, women who were very active in the social reform movement, women's organizations that had been built in India in the years between the First World War and the Second World War, all of that had happened as well. And Pankajam is also then trying to warn us gently that she cannot share, she cannot claim to have lived that life, right? She was not part of that social universe. So she is, in that sense, marking her presence as being distinct from that universe. But at the same time, I think she was also, therefore, reminding us that she was daring to write. So I think what she's doing is playing with this. So she's saying it's uneventful, and the fact that I've had just a very, very ordinary housewife's life, and yet I dare to write about my life and command your attention and your interest as a reader, means that I'm committing an act that is daring.
Speaker: 28:03
Absolutely. Actually, she is. Once we get to know her and how she railed against the expectation that a woman should be self-effacing and meek, then is all this self-effacing sort of a fiction, maybe a thinly veiled act of self of defiance, saying, I am doing what no one has done before. Is all of this a way of kind of proving how pathbreaking she is? Yes, I I
Speaker: 28:30
think I think we agree. Right. So then I'll just move on to the question of the genre, because uh we've already, you know, this book is a blend of multiple genres. There's you editing this, giving as a historian, a sociologist, as an editor, as a daughter and granddaughter. And then there's there are the multiple voices of Punkajum in her memoir, journal, voice, and then in her voice as a writer of fiction, as a writer of short stories. So how do we understand the various genres and sort of author voices and positions at work here? When describing Punkajum's short stories, which she offers to the world as fiction, in contrast to her memoirs, which she presents as nonfiction, you, as the author and editor of the book, put fiction in quotation marks as if to say the fiction is not quite fiction. Sometimes you call it thinly disguised autobiography, or you use a new term, autofiction. But how is this different from other fiction?
Speaker 2: 29:46
No, I think it was important for Pankajam to maintain that distinction inside her own head when she was writing it, uh Arvinda. It was important for her to be able to, I think, tell herself and maybe tell anybody who might just come upon this manuscript and pick it up out of curiosity and begin to read it that, oh, this is fictional. It's only a story, right? So nobody I'll know, nobody in my life is being called down or is being named or identified in this story. And these are fictional characters. See, we don't know any of these characters, their names are different. So I think it was important for Pankajam also to maintain that it was a story that she was writing and to maintain that distinction between from that and her autobiography, in which she's very explicit in using the first person narrative. She says, This is my life, these are the people in my life, this is my story. And therefore, I think I was, in a sense, honoring that. I was respecting her right to draw a line between what she declares to the world as her autobiography, the story of her life, and what she presents to the world or to her family as her fiction or her short story. So I think I was respecting that. But I think what I also make very clear in the book is that this fictional device allows her to write about what is painful, what is uncomfortable, what is fraught, the betrayals in her life. It allows her to therefore talk about conjugality, to talk about the intimate domains of her life, to talk about what it meant to be part of a very conflicted and troubled marriage. I mean, she takes you into her bedroom. So I was really taken aback when I read her stories because I realized that she was writing about what had happened in her, not just inside her household, but and that she already does in the autobiography. But what she does in these fictional stories is to take you right into her bedroom. She takes you into bedroom uh battles between a man and a woman. And that therefore gives you a sense of how conjugality was being lived out and how it was being fought over. And she keeps telling you that this is the story of Kamala, this is the story of Lakshmi, this is the story of Meena. And therefore, I think what I do is to also therefore maintain this distinction in my book and therefore use the phrase auto fiction, which is a way of saying that this was a fictionalized autobiography. It was telling of her own life, of course, but it was telling her own life through the device of fiction, which allows her then to be painfully honest and really even startlingly honest. I was taken aback when I read the stories for the first time, I must confess, because I realized that she was holding nothing back. I realized that she was bearing it all, and therefore I realized that in my book I would have to reveal everything as well.
Speaker: 32:55
Well, just to bring it back to kind of the national question, you trace how the public discourse around the status of Indian women was influenced by books such as Catherine Mayo's Mother India, which declared Indians unfit for self-rule on account of backwardness and oppression of women. So I just can't help but noticing a hundred years later, we see the same narrative on the global stage, the exploitation of the cause of women in the service of the colonial project. So, in this and so many other things, I feel like, you know, what has changed? If you could opine from your experience of immersing yourself in the worlds of your mother and grandmother in writing this book and kind of seeing how they saw the world, can you just offer any insight on what has changed and what hasn't? And how discussions of this book can awaken people the way Punkajam was awakened through her reading.
Speaker 2: 33:59
So, while I sure hope that happens, I hope people are able to pick up the book, read it, and then see contemporary resonances, see that the characters' dilemmas, the characters' joys and heartbreaks also speak to the experiences of young people today. And I really hope that happens, Advinda. But in terms of what has changed, I think Wankajum saw the world itself as something that was changing even as she was living it and experiencing it. For instance, she has a very acute sense of historical change, and she has a sense of herself as a witness to history. That's in fact how she writes about herself, saying what momentous changes I have seen. I have witnessed the world war, the anti-colonial freedom movement, the making of a new nation, changes in the great city of Madras. And she knows that she's a witness not just to large canvas, large-scale macro changes, but she's also a witness to young women's lives changing. She sees her daughter, her younger daughter in particular, Michaele. She's one of Michaeli's closest allies. She set Michaely free. So I think I say that also in my dedication, that she set her daughter free, right? So she allowed, enabled, and backed Michaele's desire for self-actualization, for independence, for travel, for mobility, for making her own personal choices and for making her political choices in her public life, etc. Pankajam was really a very, very solid friend and ally. And I think even in the 1960s, then, when she's still a housewife trapped in an unhappy marriage, right? Occasionally managing to travel and get away from her overbearing husband, she's able to see that her daughter is now in the US, in New York City, living by herself, being an independent woman, sharing a flat with a roommate, another young Indian woman. Both these girls are making a living for themselves. And Maitilee is working in the United Nations. So then she sees Maitile Lee's life bearing uh witness to this change. And I think she reacts to this change with a sense of awe and wonder that it is possible for women's lives to change so much within the span of a generation. And I think she's able to marvel at that and to also welcome it with uh with this generosity, also. No, there's a lot of generosity in her spirit and her heart. There's no bitterness because often one can also see women who feel cheated of chances, then can come down very hard on their own daughters and run daughters, right? It's a question of I managed to live with so little, a little in terms of expectations, my dreams were thwarted. So then why can't you do the same, right? But that's not Punkajam. That's not Frankajam at all. In fact, precisely because her dreams were thwarted and her mother's dreams were thwarted, she becomes one of her daughter's closest allies.
Speaker: 36:56
Yeah, it's really been a kind of an exhilarating whirlwind journey. I just have to really, really thank you for sharing this with us. I know that we will keep this conversation going, including right now. I uh hand it back to Sonica.
Speaker 1: 37:13
Thanks, Sarvinda. Um, really enjoyed your portion of the conversation.
Speaker 1: 37:17
I wanted to sort of switch a little bit and talk about the ecosystem in which Panko Jam sort of operated. There is a powerful line which shows sort of Pankujum's state of mind. It's it's on page 145 in the book, where she says, What can a mind liberated by reading do when it is trapped in a woman's body? So I think around this time, Pankujum starts to realize that the real villain isn't just somebody who is obviously the villain, like the errant husband who does not care, for instance, but the entire ecosystem of bystanding enablers, right? There are family members who claim to love you and are obviously do love you, but they stay mute or they offer empty advice while seeing your wings being clipped and yourself being reduced in real time. How do you look back at those next of kin characters who were also your kin? Were they just products of their time or did they do real unforgivable damage?
Speaker 2: 38:19
I think it was both really. Uh, that's how I would see them, uh, Sonica. I mean, I wouldn't exonerate them completely by saying that they were, after all, just, you know, a product of their times, because everybody makes a choice. There is that active agency that all of us possess, and we can choose and act in a manner that further reproduces the constraints and the limits on our daughters and our on our younger sisters, on our granddaughters, or we can choose and our daughters-in-law, or we can choose to, you know, help them make better choices than we were allowed to make. And I think when Fankajam wrote those lines about in that poem in which he says uh that it's really, and she's sort of looking at society and saying it's not just because my husband is a villain, or because my fate is bad, both of which might have happened, might have been fated to live out my life in this unhappy marriage with this villainous man. But that apart, when was I allowed to pursue my dreams or my ideals? And who was it but the people I love who turned out to then ask me to not resist, to conform? And so, really, I think she's turning around and asking every one of us. She's asking her her father played, apart from her mother, Subhalakshmi, pretty much her grandmother, her mother's uh sister, younger sister, her father, all of them really, and that whole extended network of kit and kin and cousins and clan, right? All of them play a very active part in telling a young girl to stay put in to know her place in society. And Pankajam is pointing her fingers exactly there. I think that's a question that none of us can duck. Let me also think respond to your question as a sociologist, because one of the questions we often confront in gender studies is why is it that women, older women, often are complicit in reproducing patriarchies within communities and castes, right? They are often the most important, crucial transmitters of patriarchal ideologies. And they are the most fierce and ferocious custodians and guardians of younger women's honor, quote unquote, so-called. And I think part of the reason is that, of course, that's often the only, I mean, that's the template. That's what they've known, that's what they take pride in, that's what gives them a sense of fulfillment to be playing this role. And it's also their chance to exercise power upon somebody whom they see as weaker within the system, right? Because they've had the mothers-in-law and uh mothers and unsympathetic grandmothers. And so, in turn, they become those women when they have a little opportunity to use that power. We see that happening, but then we also see there are examples of mothers and grandmothers who say, Enough, this happened with me. I had this unhappy, uh, I had this tyrannical mother-in-law, but I will not, in my turn, be a tyrannical mother-in-law to the young women who come into my family, right? I'll give them space, I'll respect their freedoms. So there is always that active choice that we are making or we are not making. I would not really take away every single person's agency to make that choice for themselves, Sonica.
Speaker 1: 41:30
And Pankajam, I think, exemplifies that that sort of second type that you said, right? I mean, she says very clearly that sort of limiting stops with her. And there are times that she questions herself as well, right? There's this back and forth that she has with her daughter, Maithali, where she's struggling with this question of giving freedom versus control and sort of negotiating those sort of dynamics. So that's very interesting.
Speaker 1: 41:55
And since we're talking a little bit about this older generation, younger generation, mother-daughter, mother-in-law, daughter-in-law, that kind of a relationship. I wanted to also ask your views, because you're sort of younger generation in this family history as well, along with being the author of this social history. So there's this question of when a child comes in an unideal marriage, right? So, of course, Panka Jam had several kids in her times as well as in ours. A key justification that people give or women themselves give for staying in less than ideal marriages or even abusive marriages would be that you're doing this for a child. Today we know statistically that kids are often better off in a single, healthy single-parent home than an unhealthy two-parent home. But statistics aren't real life. This is not how people experience it. What does a stable home mean and how much of loss of sanity can it withstand before it breaks? So after looking at Punkajim's life, what conclusions did you reach? I mean, she also made this bargain of living an outwardly conforming life, but also implementing her progressive ideals in the way she related to her next generation. But she be bore a cost for that. How do you view that bargain that she made with her situation?
Speaker 2: 43:22
Well, I think she made a devil of a bargain, didn't she? I mean, that was a circumstance, a situation in which she was well and truly trapped. She had no formal education beyond class nine, which she didn't even complete, and she didn't have a father who was willing to support her. If she walked out, if she chose to walk out of her marriage, and then one child after the other starts to arrive with unfailing regularity every two years, there's a new baby, so there's no question of her walking out and expecting somebody to help her raise her five children. And therefore, she decides then, and I don't think it was an acted choice. Because that decision had been made already about what kind of a life could she live within this constraint, within this trap. And I think she makes the best of she somehow manages to have the best possible life precisely because of her spirit, her curiosity about the world, and the fact that her spirit remains completely undefeated. And this is the remarkable thing. While she's dependent entirely on her husband financially, economically, he's the lord and master of the household, she still manages to make him irrelevant to her life. She manages to co-create this little universe with her five children, in which she takes full responsibility for raising her children, for educating them, for making them see the wonders and the mysteries of this, taking an interest in the wonders and the mysteries of the universe, etc. And she makes it very clear to her husband that she does not seek his validation, right? That he is not responsible for her happiness. And that nothing that he can do or say can take away her joy in herself and her decision to live her life to the fullest possible extent. So there is the way in which, and I think this is what I keep going back to in the book as well, that women often diminish themselves in order to be suitable partners within a marriage. Sometimes it can mean dumbing yourself down because you don't want your husband to think that you are smarter than he is, even if you know that you are just, you know, a more intelligent person than he happens to be. But it sometimes it could mean that, or or in other cases, it could just mean that you actively do not grow intellectually. You actively limit yourself so that you do not threaten your husband, so that you manage to hold on to some possibility of love in this relationship. And she was free of that desire because she liberated herself very early in the marriage of any notion that her husband was going to be a partner for her. So when she recognized that he was not going to be a partner, that he could not be a partner for her, then she decided that she must seek that partner or that companionship through so many other ways. And books was one way, friends was another way, etc. And all of that meant that, in a sense, I think she had emotionally divorced her husband, even while she continued to share a household with him, and sadly remained financially dependent on him. And I think that's what is remarkable that he managed to show him that she cared very little for what he thought of her.
Speaker 1: 46:41
I think even that is an act of it's a radical act. Because, like you said, a lot of women make this subconscious bargain more easily than at least being true to themselves and not expect what is not to be theirs. It would never be given to them in a broken relationship. So I think that's in itself a radical act, I would say.
Speaker 1: 47:03
This brings me sort of to the last question. I also read your book immediately after I read Arundhati's Roy's memoir about her mother, Mary Roy. And I couldn't help but notice some parallels. Um Mary Roy comes, you know, she's born a couple of decades after your mother, and she is more of a sort of overt rebel. So she overtly rebels within the structures of her community. Panka Jam also embodies the same spirit, but in a different garb, in a different outwardly the illusion of a conformist. Once we stop measuring a life's worth by patriarchal or modern benchmarks, what would you say? How would you summarize the true impact and consequence of Panka Jam's life to herself and to the world around her?
Speaker 2: 47:52
I would say that uh Panka Jam managed to live a life that was deeply fulfilling, I mean, by her own standards. She led a good life. And in fact, uh reading parts of the book, I felt that I was sometimes filled with envy, Sonica, believe it or not. And I felt that, oh my God, this is the life I would like to lead. Look at her spirit, look at her capacity to just rest any possibility, any little potential for joy. She was so fiercely joyful. And she was like seeking laughter and happiness and joy in, I would say, the most miserable corners of her life. And I think that was a gift. And then her capacity to love, she had a large heart. She gave of herself generously to a large number of young people in her life as well. So I would think that, and she bore, she didn't bear anybody a grudge, really. So I would think that much of, and finally, towards the end of her life, she managed to travel as well when she is able to get those free air tickets from her son who works in Air India, and she manages also with age, there's a little more freedom because your husband also gets older, his capacity to remain the authority figure that he used to be also diminishes a little bit. So all of that meant she found a little more space. To an extent, the boundaries of her life expanded. But just looking at the fact that she was able to live out her life so joyfully and with and find so much meaning and purpose in all the activities that she cultivated for herself in all her passions and interests, just completely fills me with envy. So it's the sense that it was such a rich life, such a meaningful life, such a joyful life. I think my biggest takeaway from this book, and that's what I hope that the readers of this book will be able to actually also discover for themselves, the impact on her daughters, of course, and on me as her granddaughter. I mean, as I say in the book, she was my primary caregiver when I was growing up, when I was a little child. I had her constant company, and I think it has been formative of me in so many ways, and certainly of my mother as well. To a large extent, uh Maitali was Maitili because her mother was Pankajam, and there's no denying that at all. And even after she chose to be in politics, to be in public life, it was Pankajam's constant presence, support, and care labor, racing Maitali's daughter, racing me, that allowed Maitali to be this full-time trade unionist, full-time organizer, full-time movement person. And therefore, you see how Pankajam was this enormous pillar of strength for both Maitali and and also for me. I absolutely have to credit her with having played a tremendous role in my life.
Speaker 1: 50:41
I couldn't agree more with everything you said.
Speaker 1: 50:44
I personally found this book so uplifting, so motivating, and really so surprisingly relevant, even in our times. Personally, for me, Kalpana, this book of yours, arrived on my bedside table at a time in my life where I was in a very introspective mode on gender relations, given a major event in my immediate family. And reading this book and this discussion has been so interesting and so illuminating and also cathartic for me. If Punkajum could give the world the rich and copious contributions given her life circumstances, I have no excuse. So I want as many people, men, women, and children, and everyone in between, to go get a copy of this book and read it for themselves. I hope this conversation has inspired people to go grab your book. To listeners who got up to this point, please do subscribe to our podcast. And the first five listeners to leave a review on this episode will get a free copy of the book, A Woman of No Consequence, shipped to your address. I want to thank from the bottom of my heart, Kalpana, for sitting down and having this conversation with us. I look forward to having a similar conversation with your next book.
Speaker 2: 51:59
Thank you so much, Sonica. Thank you so much, Arvinda. And I enjoyed this conversation. I'm so thankful for the warm appreciation of my book, both of you. And this was a fantastic conversation. And I look forward to the first five comments on this episode of the podcast.
Speaker 1: 52:18
All right. Thanks everyone. Until next time. Bye. Roots to Grassroots is made possible by Association for India's Development or Aid, a 501c3 charitable organization advancing sustainable development, social justice, and disaster relief in India. A guiding mantra of AIDS is that interconnected problems call for interconnected solutions. Aid supports grassroots projects in the areas of gender, livelihood, environment, health, education, rights, and sustainable agriculture, driven by experiences and perspectives of communities who have been marginalized by prevailing socioeconomic structures. Learn more about aid at www.aidindia.org. If you like this episode, consider making a donation on the Aid website so we can bring more grounded voices from the grassroots to you.